Grading the Draft: Complete Analysis for Round 1 of the 2025 NFL Draft
Welcome to the Gauntlet: 2025 NFL Draft First-Round Grades
No fluff. No filters. Just cold, hard truths.
The first round of the 2025 NFL Draft is in the books—and now it’s time to separate the steals from the reaches, the masterminds from the mayhem. We’re grading every single pick, from No. 1 to 32, with zero apologies and plenty of heat.
Did your team crush it or completely whiff on a franchise-altering decision? We watched every snap, read every scouting report, and now we’re holding teams accountable. No pick goes unjudged. No front office is safe.
This is the article GMs don’t want you to read.
This is The Draft Scout.
🔥 Want to know which teams walked away with A+ hauls and which ones deserve a full organizational audit?
🔥 Want over 300 in-depth scouting reports, mock drafts, and inside info that gives you a jumpstart on 2026?
Subscribe now and download the full 2025 Draft Guide. Then buckle up and dive into the round-by-round breakdown that fans, insiders, and haters will be talking about all week.
Let’s grade some damn picks.
1.1 Tennessee Titans — Cam Ward, QB, Miami (FL)
Grade: B
The Titans swinging for the fences with Cam Ward at No. 1 overall is gutsy, no question. Ward has the raw tools: live arm, natural athleticism, and the ability to extend plays when the structure breaks down. At his best, he flashes Mahomes-lite moments with daring throws and creative off-script magic. If Tennessee’s evaluating staff believes he can be molded into a top-tier quarterback, the pick could age well.
But “could” is doing a lot of work here.
Ward isn’t a finished product. His tape shows inconsistent footwork, streaky accuracy, and decision-making that sometimes leaves you scratching your head. He improved in 2024, but he’s still a projection-heavy player who needs a tailored scheme and patience. Taking him first overall means the Titans passed on safer options—or traded away the chance to collect a haul of picks.
There’s boom potential here, but also a bust floor that feels lower than you’d like for the top pick. It’s a bet on upside, and if they’re wrong, this move could set the franchise back years. It’s aggressive, it’s flashy, and it’s risky as hell.
1.2 Jacksonville Jaguars (via Cleveland) — Travis Hunter, CB/WR, Colorado
Grade: A
The Jacksonville Jaguars trading up to No. 2 overall to select Travis Hunter is a bold and high-reward move. By making this trade, they secure one of the most dynamic and versatile players in the draft—Hunter’s ability to play both wide receiver and cornerback gives him an elite two-way impact. At 6’1” with excellent athleticism and a rare combination of ball skills and defensive instincts, Hunter stands out as one of the most complete prospects in recent memory.
On offense, Hunter’s quickness, route running, and strong hands make him a dangerous weapon in the passing game, while his physicality and ability to track the ball give him a serious edge as a cornerback. His versatility is a game-changer for the Jaguars, potentially allowing them to move him around based on matchups, maximizing his impact across multiple positions.
This move is also indicative of a forward-thinking, aggressive approach to building a championship-caliber team. Pairing Hunter with Trevor Lawrence and the growing offensive weapons in Jacksonville gives the Jaguars the potential to be a threat on both sides of the ball.
Overall, this is a franchise-defining selection with immediate and long-term implications for the team’s success.
1.3 New York Giants — Abdul Carter, DE, Penn State
Grade: A
The New York Giants snagging Abdul Carter at No. 3 overall is the kind of jolt this franchise desperately needed. Forget positional value debates—this is a culture pick. A tone-setter. A guy who shows up on day one and makes everyone around him play faster, tougher, and meaner. Carter is an alpha in every sense of the word, and now he’s the face of a defensive rebuild in New York.
Built like an edge rusher and moving like a safety, Carter brings rare explosiveness and violent intentions to every snap. He’s a matchup eraser who can blitz, cover, chase, and destroy. Whether it’s tracking down mobile quarterbacks or blowing up run plays from the backside, he plays with his hair on fire and hits like a freight train. Simply put: he lives in the backfield.
The Giants didn’t overthink this. They saw a freak athlete, a modern linebacker who thrives in chaos, and they turned in the card. With Carter, Brian Burns and Kayvon Thibodeaux now sharing a front seven, NFC East offenses just got a whole lot more nervous.
This is how you rebuild a defense—with speed, violence, and juice. Carter brings all three. Giant move, literally and figuratively.
1.4 New England Patriots
Grade: A+
With the No. 4 overall pick, the New England Patriots made an exceptional move by selecting Will Campbell, the powerhouse offensive tackle from LSU. Campbell’s combination of size, strength, and technical ability is unmatched in this class. At 6’6” and 325 pounds, he’s a force to be reckoned with in the trenches. His quick first step and powerful hands allow him to dominate in both run blocking and pass protection. Campbell is a physical specimen with the agility to excel in the modern NFL, making him a top-tier talent at a premium position.
The Patriots have been searching for a franchise left tackle and solidify their offensive line for years to come. With Campbell, they not only fill a significant need but also get a player who is ready to start immediately and develop into a cornerstone for the future. His technical skills and ability to overpower defenders will instantly bolster New England’s running game and pass protection, offering Drake Maye the support he desperately needs to reach his potential.
Will Campbell is a perfect fit for the Patriots at No. 4. This pick fills a glaring hole, provides instant impact, and offers long-term stability. A home run for New England, both for today and the future.
1.5 Cleveland Browns (from Jacksonville) — Mason Graham, DT, Michigan
Grade: B-
The Cleveland Browns’ decision to trade back from No. 2 overall to No. 5 and select Michigan defensive tackle Mason Graham is a savvy move, but with some inherent risks. First, trading back and still securing Graham, a talented and disruptive force on the interior, indicates solid roster management and a keen sense of value. Graham, at 6’3” and 300 pounds, has the frame to dominate both as a pass rusher and run stopper. His ability to collapse pockets and his powerful hand usage make him a great addition to the Browns’ defensive line, especially in a division that values physicality.
However, while Graham is a solid player with high potential, the Browns are passing up an opportunity to select one of the draft’s top elite talents at No. 2, which carries a slight risk. The gap in perceived talent between Graham and the player they might have selected at No. 2 could affect the long-term value of this trade, depending on how the rest of the draft unfolds.
Overall, this pick represents a calculated risk. The Browns fill a need along their defensive front and add a versatile player in Graham, but the decision to move back while still getting him at No. 5 adds uncertainty. It’s a solid choice but with some degree of potential upside and downside.
1.6 Las Vegas Raiders—Ashton Jeanty, RB, Boise State
Grade: A+
Selecting Ashton Jeanty at No. 6 overall is a home run for the Las Vegas Raiders. This is an absolutely stellar pick, as Jeanty is not just one of the top running back prospects in the draft—he’s arguably one of the most complete offensive weapons available. His combination of vision, burst, agility, and pass-catching ability gives him the potential to be an all-purpose, game-changing player from day one.
Jeanty’s ability to make defenders miss in tight spaces, coupled with his breakaway speed, makes him a serious threat on every down. His smoothness as a receiver out of the backfield further elevates his value, making him a matchup nightmare for defenses. The Raiders, who are looking to build a more explosive offense, have struck gold by adding a player who can be a central figure in both the running and passing game.
At No. 6 overall, this is a rare pick for a running back at the top of the draft, but Jeanty’s skill set warrants it. His immediate impact as a focal point of the offense, paired with his long-term potential, makes this a franchise-altering move. The Raiders have found a player who can be the centerpiece of their offense for years to come, making this an A+ selection.
1.7 New York Jets — Armand Membou, T, Missouri
Grade: B+
The New York Jets selecting Armand Membou at No. 7 overall is a bold, high-upside pick, but with notable risk. Membou, an athletic and powerful defensive prospect, brings a lot of physical tools to the table. Standing at 6’5” and possessing exceptional strength and explosion off the line, he has the traits of a dominant edge rusher or disruptive interior player. His ability to apply pressure and disrupt plays in both the run and pass game is intriguing, and he could add a major piece to the Jets’ already strong defense.
However, Membou’s rawness in some areas raises questions. While his athleticism is undeniable, his technique and consistency still need refinement at the professional level. There are moments where he relies more on his physical gifts than on refined skill, which could result in developmental challenges.
For a team like the Jets, who are already a strong contender with an established defense, selecting a player who may need time to develop could be seen as a gamble. If the Jets have the resources to refine his skills, this pick could turn into a fantastic one, but there’s still significant uncertainty around how quickly he’ll adjust to the NFL.
Overall, it’s a solid pick with significant upside but some risks attached, so it lands in the high B range.
1.8 Carolina Panthers — Tetairoa McMillan, WR, Arizona
Grade: A-
The Carolina Panthers selecting TET McMillian at No. 8 overall is a strong pick, particularly when considering the need to support their newly drafted quarterback, Bryce Young. McMillian, a 6’4” wide receiver, offers a perfect complement to Young’s style of play, providing a big target that can make tough catches in critical situations. His size and physicality help create mismatches against smaller cornerbacks, while his ability to go up and high-point the ball gives Young a reliable red-zone option.
McMillian’s combination of size, ball skills, and ability to win contested catches makes him a perfect fit in Carolina’s offensive plans. His ability to stretch the field and make explosive plays downfield will not only support Young’s development but also elevate the passing game overall.
However, while McMillian has a lot of potential, his route running and consistency can still be refined to maximize his ability at the next level. There are moments where his separation from defenders can be inconsistent, which could limit his immediate impact.
Overall, this is an excellent pick that directly addresses the Panthers’ need for a dynamic receiving option to grow alongside their young quarterback. With some development, McMillian could become a cornerstone of Carolina’s offense, making this pick a strong A-.
1.9 New Orleans Saints — Kelvin Banks Jr., T, Texas
Grade: A
The New Orleans Saints selecting Kelvin Banks Jr. is an excellent pick. Banks, a 6’5” offensive tackle from Texas, is one of the top blockers in the draft, and his addition immediately strengthens the Saints’ offensive line. His size, strength, and quickness make him a dominant force in both the run and pass game. With an ability to protect the quarterback’s blind side and create lanes in the running game, Banks offers the Saints a future star at a critical position.
What makes this pick particularly smart is that the Saints are investing in their offensive line to help protect their quarterback and establish a more consistent ground game. Banks has the physical traits to dominate at the next level and is polished enough to start from day one, which provides immediate value to a team looking to compete in the near future.
While there are areas where he can still refine his technique, particularly in his hand placement and blocking angles, his natural athleticism and physicality give him a high ceiling.
Overall, this is a great pick, as it fills a significant need for the Saints while providing them with a player who can be an anchor for their offensive line for years to come.
1.10 Chicago Bears — Colston Loveland, TE, Michigan
Grade: A+
The Chicago Bears selecting Colston Loveland is a phenomenal pick, and it’s an A+ decision for the franchise. Loveland, a versatile tight end with exceptional athleticism and ball skills, is a player who can immediately impact the Bears’ offense in a major way. His 6’5” frame, combined with his fluid movement and ability to create separation from defenders, gives him the potential to be a key target in the passing game. Loveland’s ability to stretch the field and make tough catches across the middle will be invaluable as the Bears continue to build their offensive identity.
What makes this pick even more impressive is how closely Loveland mirrors the type of player that Sam LaPorta was in Detroit for Ben Johnson. Like LaPorta, Loveland combines size with a strong catch radius, creating mismatches against smaller defensive backs and linebackers. Both players possess an innate understanding of the game, a knack for finding soft spots in the defense, and a reliability as possession receivers in key moments.
Loveland’s ability to align in-line, in the slot, or even split wide further enhances his value as a multi-dimensional weapon, making him an ideal fit for the Bears’ evolving offense. His route running and ability to gain yards after the catch are his standout attributes, and with some coaching refinement, he could become one of the most dangerous tight ends in the league.
Overall, this is an A+ pick for the Bears. They’ve secured a player who can contribute immediately and has the potential to be a major piece in their offense for years to come.
1.11 San Francisco 49ers — Mykel Williams, DE, Georgia
Grade: B
The San Francisco 49ers selecting Mykel Williams at No. 11 overall is a solid pick, but it feels a bit underwhelming given the other options on the board. Williams, a 6’5” defensive end from Georgia, brings impressive size and length to the table, as well as strong pass-rushing potential. His burst off the line and ability to get after the quarterback are strengths that could help improve the 49ers’ already stout defensive line.
However, the lukewarm feeling comes from a few key concerns. Williams’ consistency can be an issue, particularly when it comes to his technique and finishing plays. At times, he relies too heavily on his physical gifts and doesn’t always show the refined skill needed to dominate at the next level. While his raw talent is undeniable, he may require more time to develop than some of the other top defensive prospects available at No. 11.
That said, Williams has the potential to grow into a key player for the 49ers if he’s coached up properly, especially considering the team’s excellent defensive infrastructure. However, for a team with playoff aspirations, this pick could feel more like a project rather than an immediate impact player, which is why it lands in the B range.
1.12 Dallas Cowboys — Tyler Booker, G, Alabama
Grade: A
The Dallas Cowboys selecting Tyler Booker at No. 12 overall is a fantastic pick that addresses a key need along the offensive line. Booker, a versatile and powerful interior offensive lineman from Alabama, has the tools to step in and contribute immediately. Standing at 6’5” and 325 pounds, he brings the strength, agility, and nastiness required to dominate at the next level. His ability to play both guard and tackle offers significant flexibility, allowing the Cowboys to shore up multiple spots on the offensive line.
What makes this pick so strong is Booker’s combination of physicality and technique. He has the ability to move defenders off the ball in the run game and protect the quarterback in pass protection. His work ethic and leadership on the field are also standout qualities, as he consistently displays an intensity that will fit perfectly in Dallas’ culture.
The Cowboys have made a smart decision here, adding a player who can start immediately and contribute to both the run and passing game. Booker’s skill set will help solidify an already strong offensive line, making this an A pick that supports the team’s long-term success.
1.13 Miami Dolphins — Kenneth Grant, DT, Michigan
Grade: C+
The Miami Dolphins selecting Kenneth Grant at No. 13 overall is an average pick that has both promise and some question marks. Grant, a massive defensive tackle at 6’4” and 340 pounds, brings a powerful presence to the interior of the defensive line. His ability to clog running lanes and occupy blockers gives him the potential to be a key cog in the Dolphins’ defensive scheme. As a run-stopper, he’s likely to make an immediate impact and help improve Miami’s defensive front.
However, the reason this pick feels average is due to Grant’s limitations in terms of pass rush and overall athleticism. While he’s incredibly strong and can take up space, his lack of explosiveness and refined pass-rush techniques could limit his effectiveness on passing downs. There are concerns about whether he can consistently contribute to the pass rush at the next level, which could make him more of a two-down player rather than a full-time difference-maker.
For a team like the Dolphins, who are looking to build on their competitive roster, this feels like a safe but somewhat underwhelming pick at No. 13. Grant’s ability to contribute immediately in stopping the run is valuable, but the lack of pass-rush upside brings the grade down to a C+.
1.14 Indianapolis Colts — Tyler Warren, TE, Penn State
Grade: A+
The Indianapolis Colts selecting Tyler Warren at No. 14 overall is an A+ pick. Warren, a dynamic and versatile tight end, is a perfect fit for the Colts as they continue to build around their young quarterback and strengthen their offense. At 6’6” with excellent athleticism and soft hands, Warren offers a rare combination of size, speed, and route-running ability that can make him a matchup nightmare for defenses.
Warren’s ability to line up both in-line and in the slot gives the Colts incredible flexibility in their offensive scheme. He’s not just a pass-catching threat—he’s a strong blocker as well, making him an ideal two-way tight end who can contribute immediately in both the running game and passing game. His ability to stretch the field vertically, along with his proficiency in creating separation and catching passes in tight coverage, makes him a dangerous weapon for the Colts’ offense.
With a young quarterback under center, adding a player like Warren can help ease their transition, giving them a reliable security blanket in the passing game. He’s a player who can make an immediate impact and be a cornerstone for the offense for years to come. This is a top-tier selection and an A+ move by the Colts to add a player of Warren’s caliber to their offense.
1.15 Atlanta Falcons — Jalon Walker, DE, Georgia
Grade: A+
The Atlanta Falcons selecting Jalon Walker is a home-run pick and earns an A+ grade. Walker, a versatile and explosive linebacker from Georgia, offers the perfect blend of speed, athleticism, and football IQ to fit into the Falcons’ defense. At 6’2” with excellent range and coverage ability, Walker excels in both pass coverage and as a run defender. His ability to rush the passer and drop into coverage gives defensive coordinators incredible flexibility, allowing them to utilize him in multiple roles.
Walker’s high motor, coupled with his leadership and playmaking ability, makes him an immediate impact player. Whether it’s tracking down ball carriers, disrupting passing lanes, or sacking the quarterback, he has the skill set to contribute across the board. His athleticism allows him to cover ground quickly, and he’s equally adept at playing in space or setting the edge against the run.
For the Falcons, this pick addresses a crucial need while providing them with a player who can immediately start and help improve their defense in multiple ways. His potential as a long-term cornerstone of the defense is enormous. With Walker, the Falcons not only fill a positional need but also acquire one of the most talented and versatile linebackers in the draft. This is an A+ pick that will pay dividends for years to come.
1.16 Arizona Cardinals — Walter Nolen, DT, Ole Miss
Grade: A-
The Arizona Cardinals selecting Walter Nolen at No. 16 overall is an exciting, high-upside pick. Nolen, a 6’4” and 320-pound defensive tackle, has elite physical traits and immense potential. His combination of size, strength, and athleticism is rare for a player at his position, and his ability to disrupt the line of scrimmage in both the run and pass game makes him a versatile and valuable addition to the Cardinals’ defensive front.
Nolen’s raw talent is undeniable. He can penetrate into the backfield with quickness and power, forcing quarterbacks to make quick decisions and disrupting offensive game plans. His upside as a pass rusher, particularly from the interior, is considerable, and he has the potential to develop into a dominant force in the NFL with further refinement of his technique and consistency.
However, the high upside also comes with some risks. Nolen can be inconsistent in terms of motor and execution, and his technique needs polishing. If he can develop into a more disciplined player and harness his physical gifts, Nolen has the potential to be one of the top defensive tackles in the league.
Overall, this is a pick with great potential. The Cardinals are betting on his development, and if they can maximize his talents, Nolen could become a cornerstone of their defense. This makes it an A- grade, balancing the excitement of his upside with the need for refinement.
1.17 Cincinnati Bengals — Shemar Stewart, DE, Texas A&M
Grade: B+
The Cincinnati Bengals selecting Shemar Stewart is a solid pick with notable upside, earning a B+ grade. Stewart, a 6’5”, 305-pound defensive lineman, has all the physical tools to become a dominant force at the next level. His combination of size, strength, and athleticism makes him a physical presence on the defensive line, and he has the potential to wreak havoc as both a pass rusher and run defender.
However, Stewart’s lack of consistent production in college raises some questions. While his potential is high, he hasn’t always been able to put it together on a regular basis. At times, he struggles with motor consistency and tends to disappear in games, which is concerning for a player with his profile. His lack of production relative to his physical gifts means he could take time to develop into the type of player his upside suggests.
That said, the Bengals are in a strong position to develop Stewart, and his tools make him an intriguing long-term project. With the right coaching, he has the potential to be a game-changer along the defensive line, making this a high-reward pick. If Stewart can refine his technique and maximize his potential, this pick could turn into a steal for the Bengals.
Overall, the grade is B+ due to the high potential but also the uncertainty around his ability to consistently produce at the next level.
1.18 Seattle Seahawks — Grey Zabel, OL, North Dakota State
Grade: B
The Seattle Seahawks selecting Grey Zabel at No. 19 overall is a solid pick, but it feels a bit on the conservative side given other available options. Zabel, an athletic and versatile offensive lineman, brings a great combination of size, mobility, and potential to the Seahawks’ offensive line. At 6’6” and 320 pounds, he has the frame to dominate as both a pass protector and run blocker, and his agility allows him to move efficiently in space.
However, there are some concerns regarding Zabel’s consistency and refinement in key areas. While he has the raw tools to be an effective starter, his technique can sometimes be sloppy, particularly in hand placement and footwork. There’s also some uncertainty about how well he’ll transition to the NFL in terms of physicality, especially against more elite defensive linemen.
For a team like the Seahawks, who are looking to strengthen their offensive line and continue building a more balanced offense, Zabel is a good fit, but the pick doesn’t have the immediate star potential of some other players on the board. He’s a developmental pick with the ability to start and grow into a solid contributor, but his upside might take some time to fully materialize.
Overall, it’s a dependable pick with room for growth, earning a B grade for its solid but unspectacular nature.
1.19 Tampa Bay Buccaneers — Emeka Egbuka, WR, Ohio State
Grade: A-
The Tampa Bay Buccaneers selecting Emeka Egbuka at No. 19 overall is a strong pick, and it fills a need while adding a dynamic playmaker to their offense. Egbuka, a 6’0” wide receiver from Ohio State, possesses elite athleticism, quickness, and ball skills. His ability to create separation with smooth route running and his excellent hands make him a threat at all levels of the field. Egbuka is also a capable after-the-catch receiver, with the vision and elusiveness to turn short passes into big gains.
What makes this pick particularly appealing for the Buccaneers is the addition of a true No. 1 receiver who can contribute immediately. With the uncertainty surrounding Tampa Bay’s quarterback situation, having a reliable target like Egbuka will help stabilize the passing game. His polished route tree and ability to win at the line of scrimmage will make him an instant asset, whether he’s paired with a veteran QB or a younger signal-caller.
The slight hesitation for an A grade stems from Egbuka’s fit in the NFL. While his skill set is impressive, there are moments when he can be more inconsistent in physical matchups, particularly against more physical corners. Nonetheless, his overall potential, versatility, and high floor make this an excellent selection for the Buccaneers.
Overall, this is an A- pick, as it provides Tampa Bay with a weapon who can immediately make an impact and develop into a key part of their offense for years to come
1.20 Denver Broncos — Jahdae Barron, CB, Texas
Grade: B
The Denver Broncos selecting Jahdae Barron at No. 20 overall is a solid pick, but it carries some risk. Barron, a cornerback from Texas, is an aggressive, athletic defender with the ability to cover a wide range of receivers. His 5’11” frame, combined with excellent speed and ball skills, gives him the potential to be a versatile and effective piece in the secondary.
Barron’s ability to track the ball, make plays in the air, and cover both inside and outside receivers is valuable, and he’s shown strong potential to contribute immediately. His toughness and competitive nature make him a great fit for the Broncos’ defense, which emphasizes physicality and hard-nosed play.
However, the concerns with Barron lie in his occasional lapses in coverage and inconsistency with his technique. While he has the physical traits to thrive, his development in terms of refining his footwork, reading route concepts, and adjusting to NFL-level competition will be key to his success. There are moments where his lack of refinement can lead to blown coverages or missed opportunities.
For the Broncos, this pick provides a high-upside cornerback who can step in and be a contributor right away, but his development will be crucial. The high ceiling and areas for improvement balance out to a B grade, as it’s a pick with both immediate value and potential long-term reward.
1.21 Pittsburgh Steelers — Derrick Harmon, DT, Oregon
Grade: B+
The Pittsburgh Steelers selecting Derrick Harmon at No. 21 overall is a strong pick, though it comes with some mixed feelings regarding its long-term impact. Harmon, a defensive lineman from Alabama, is a highly athletic and powerful player who can be an immediate disruptor in both the run and pass game. His 6’4”, 305-pound frame is ideal for a 3-4 defensive front, and he has the flexibility to line up both inside and on the edge, providing versatility to the Steelers’ defense.
Harmon’s explosiveness off the line and ability to collapse pockets are standout traits. He has the potential to be a force in the trenches, creating chaos for offensive lines and quarterbacks. His motor and drive to finish plays set him apart from other defensive linemen, and he could immediately make an impact as a rotational player while developing into a full-time starter.
However, Harmon’s consistency and technique remain areas of growth. While his raw talent is undeniable, he still needs to refine his hand placement, leverage, and overall pass-rush moves. His production at times was sporadic in college, which raises questions about his ability to maintain that level of performance consistently in the NFL.
Overall, this is a solid pick with upside. Harmon fits well into the Steelers’ defensive philosophy and can contribute right away, but his continued development will be key to determining his long-term success. The B+ grade reflects a solid value pick with room for growth.
1.22 Los Angeles Chargers — Omarion Hampton, RB, North Carolina
Grade: A-
The Los Angeles Chargers selecting Omarion Hampton at No. 22 overall is a strong, well-rounded pick that fills a need and provides immediate impact. Hampton, a dynamic running back from North Carolina, brings a rare combination of size, speed, and agility to the Chargers’ backfield. At 6’1” and 220 pounds, he has the physicality to break tackles and the quickness to make defenders miss in space. His vision and burst through the line of scrimmage are excellent, and he possesses the ability to contribute both as a rusher and in the passing game.
Hampton’s ability to catch passes out of the backfield adds tremendous value, allowing the Chargers to utilize him in various offensive schemes. This versatility helps complement their existing offense and gives quarterback Justin Herbert a reliable, multidimensional weapon in the backfield. His presence will likely help balance the offense and keep defenses on their heels, especially with the passing game already being a major threat in Los Angeles.
The slight hesitation for an A grade stems from Hampton’s need to further refine his pass protection and consistency in terms of ball security, but these are fixable areas with proper coaching.
Overall, this is an A- pick, as Hampton can contribute right away and has the potential to be a feature back for years to come, helping elevate the Chargers’ offense.
1.23 Green Bay Packers — Matthew Golden, WR, Texas
Grade: A+
The Green Bay Packers selecting Matthew Golden at No. 23 overall is an A+ pick that could have a major impact on their offense. Golden, a wide receiver from Houston, is a playmaker who combines elite speed, exceptional route-running, and natural hands to create separation from defenders. Standing at 6’2” with the ability to stretch the field vertically, Golden offers a dynamic threat in both deep and short-range situations, making him a perfect complement to the Packers’ evolving offensive scheme.
Golden’s ability to make tough catches in traffic and his knack for creating big plays downfield make him a versatile weapon who can be used in a variety of roles. His agility, quickness, and high football IQ allow him to work both on the perimeter and in the slot, providing Aaron Rodgers—or his potential successor—with a reliable target for years to come.
With the Packers looking to build around a young quarterback, adding Golden is a smart move to ensure they have the weapons needed to develop a potent passing attack. His potential as a long-term No. 1 receiver, combined with his immediate ability to contribute, makes him an excellent fit for Green Bay.
This is a high-upside pick with immediate and long-term value, making it an A+ decision for the Packers.
1.24 Minnesota Vikings — Donovan Jackson, G, Ohio State
Grade: B+
The Minnesota Vikings selecting Donovan Jackson at No. 23 overall is a solid, high-value pick. Jackson, an interior offensive lineman from Ohio State, is a powerful and technically sound player who can step in and contribute immediately to the Vikings’ offensive line. His 6’4”, 310-pound frame and elite strength allow him to excel as both a pass protector and a run blocker. Jackson’s ability to drive defenders off the ball in the running game, combined with his ability to protect the quarterback in pass protection, makes him an ideal fit for a team looking to shore up its offensive line.
What makes this pick particularly valuable is Jackson’s versatility. He has experience playing multiple positions along the interior line, which gives the Vikings flexibility in how they utilize him. His leadership, football IQ, and consistency provide a steadying presence in the middle of the offensive line.
However, the B+ grade comes with the understanding that while Jackson is solid across the board, he doesn’t have the same high-end upside as some other offensive line prospects in this draft. His technique and ability to adjust to NFL-level speed and power will be key to his development.
Overall, this is a great pick for the Vikings, addressing a critical need with a player who can contribute right away and continue to improve. His reliability and strength make this a smart and safe choice, earning a B+ grade.
1.25 New York Giants (from Houston) — Jaxson Dart, QB, Ole Miss
Grade: B
The New York Giants trading up to No. 25 to select Jaxson Dart is an intriguing move, but it comes with a mix of excitement and caution. Dart, a highly talented quarterback from Ole Miss, possesses strong arm strength, mobility, and the ability to make all the throws necessary to succeed at the next level. His dual-threat capabilities—ability to make plays both in and out of the pocket—offer tremendous upside, particularly in a system that values quarterback mobility and adaptability.
However, the trade-up to select Dart raises a few questions. While Dart’s talent is evident, he is still a bit raw, particularly in terms of decision-making and consistency. His mechanics, while solid, still need refinement, and his performance against top-tier competition has shown moments of inconsistency. Moving up to select a quarterback who may need more development than a higher-round pick would suggest adds an element of risk, especially given the premium paid for the trade-up.
For the Giants, who already have a competent starting quarterback, the decision to trade up for Dart might indicate a longer-term play. It’s possible that they see Dart as the future of the franchise, but with his development still a work in progress, there could be a few years of waiting before he’s ready to step into a full-time starting role.
Overall, this pick feels like a gamble with significant upside but comes with a certain level of risk. The trade-up was bold, but Dart’s potential makes this a B-grade pick—solid, but not without its uncertainties.
1.26 Atlanta Falcons (from LA Rams — James Pearce Jr., DE, Tennessee
Grade: A
The Atlanta Falcons trading up to No. 26 to select James Pearce Jr. from Tennessee is a great move that bolsters their pass rush and strengthens their defensive front. Pearce, a dynamic and explosive edge rusher, has a relentless motor and the ability to disrupt plays from the edge. His quickness off the line, combined with his ability to bend around blockers and get to the quarterback, makes him an immediate threat as a pass rusher.
What makes this trade-up particularly impressive is that the Falcons are addressing a significant need at a premium position—edge rusher—while also acquiring a player who has the potential to make an immediate impact. Pearce has shown the ability to generate pressure consistently and will be a perfect fit in the Falcons’ defensive scheme, which prioritizes generating pressure and creating chaos in the backfield. His size, athleticism, and pass-rush potential give him a high ceiling as a starter and potential future star in the NFL.
The trade-up was well worth it, as Pearce’s upside makes him a valuable addition, and his skill set directly contributes to the Falcons’ defensive goals. Given his combination of explosiveness, technique, and relentless pursuit, Pearce is a player who can immediately contribute and develop into a cornerstone of the defense.
Overall, this is an A-grade pick for the Falcons. The move up to No. 26 to secure Pearce was smart, as he provides a high-reward player with the potential to make an immediate and long-term impact on their defense.
1.27 Baltimore Ravens — Malaki Starks, S, Georgia
Grade: A+
The Baltimore Ravens selecting Malaki Starks is an A+ pick. Starks, a dynamic and versatile safety from Georgia, brings everything you want in a modern defensive back. Standing at 6’1” with exceptional athleticism, Starks has the range, instincts, and physicality to be a game-changer in both pass coverage and run support. His ability to cover a lot of ground quickly and make plays on the ball, whether it’s intercepting passes or breaking up throws, makes him an ideal fit for the Ravens’ defense, which thrives on aggressive, ball-hawking play.
What makes this pick so impactful is Starks’ versatility. He’s capable of playing as a deep safety, in the box, or even in a slot role, allowing the Ravens to move him around based on matchups and game situations. His high football IQ and leadership qualities further enhance his value, as he can be a captain in the secondary for years to come.
The Ravens have a history of developing standout defensive players, and Starks has the potential to follow in that tradition. Given his all-around ability and high upside, this is a pick that immediately improves the defense and provides long-term stability.
Overall, Starks is a player who can make an immediate impact and develop into a cornerstone of the Ravens’ defense. His combination of skill, athleticism, and versatility makes this an A+ selection.
1.28 Detroit Lions — Tyleik Williams, DT, Ohio State
Grade: C
The Detroit Lions selecting Tyleik Williams at No. 28 overall is a questionable pick, and the grade reflects concerns about the value of the selection. Williams, a defensive tackle from Ohio State, has a lot of physical tools—standing at 6’3” and 335 pounds with solid athleticism—but his production and consistency leave something to be desired. While he has flashes of brilliance with the ability to disrupt plays, his overall performance, particularly in terms of consistency and technique, doesn’t match the value typically expected at No. 28 overall.
At this stage of the draft, the Lions could have looked at other positions of need, such as wide receiver, edge rusher, or even cornerback, where there were potentially higher-impact players available. Williams may project as a solid rotational defensive lineman who could develop into a starter over time, but the pick feels like it might have been better spent elsewhere, especially considering the overall depth of the draft class in other areas of need for Detroit.
While Williams has some upside and could develop into a strong interior presence with the right coaching, the value at No. 28 overall doesn’t quite align with his current level of play and potential immediate impact. As such, this selection feels more like a reach, which is why it earns a C grade.
1.29 Washington Commanders — Josh Conerly Jr., T, Oregon
Grade: B
The Washington Commanders selecting Josh Conerly Jr. at No. 29 overall is an excellent pick. Conerly, a highly athletic offensive tackle from Oregon, brings great physical tools and versatility to the Commanders’ offensive line. At 6’5” and 310 pounds, he has the size and mobility to play either tackle spot at the next level. His footwork and quickness off the line make him a dynamic blocker, particularly in pass protection, where he shows the ability to move well in space and protect the quarterback’s blind side.
What makes this pick particularly strong is the Commanders’ need to continue fortifying their offensive line. Conerly has the upside to be a starting left tackle for years to come, and his smooth technique and ability to handle speed rushers make him an ideal fit for Washington’s offense, which will need solid protection for their quarterbacks moving forward.
While Conerly still has room for improvement in terms of consistency, particularly with hand placement and maintaining leverage in the run game, his overall skill set and ceiling are impressive. With the right coaching and development, he has the potential to be a cornerstone piece on the Commanders’ offensive line.
Overall, this is a B pick. The Commanders addressed a key need and added a player who can step in and contribute immediately while developing into a top-tier tackle for the long term.
1.30 Buffalo Bills — Maxwell Hairston, CB, Kentucky
Grade: B
The Buffalo Bills selecting Maxwell Hairston, cornerback from Kentucky, is a solid pick that addresses a need in the secondary. Hairston is a talented, athletic cornerback with the ability to cover a wide range of receivers. At 6’1” with good length and speed, he offers the physical traits that are coveted in an NFL corner. His ability to disrupt passes, cover multiple routes, and provide solid run support makes him a versatile addition to the Bills’ defense.
However, the B grade stems from concerns about Hairston’s consistency and technique. While he has impressive physical tools, his coverage skills can be inconsistent, and he has moments of poor positioning that leave him vulnerable against more polished NFL wide receivers. Additionally, his ability to adjust to the speed of the NFL game will be crucial for his development.
That said, Hairston has a high ceiling and, with proper coaching and development, can become a starter in the league. Buffalo is known for developing talent in its secondary, and Hairston fits the mold of a player who can be a long-term contributor if he refines his technique.
Overall, this is a solid pick with upside, though it comes with some risk in terms of development. The B grade reflects the value of adding a physical corner with potential, but it also acknowledges that Hairston will need time to adjust and improve his consistency.
1.31 Philadelphia Eagles (from Kansas City) — Jihaad Campbell, LB, Alabama
Grade: A
The Philadelphia Eagles trading up from No. 32 to No. 31 overall to select Jihaad Campbell is an excellent move, earning an A grade. Campbell, a linebacker from Alabama, brings a rare combination of speed, agility, and football intelligence to the Eagles’ defense. At 6’2” and 230 pounds, Campbell has the size and athleticism to be an immediate impact player, whether he’s tracking down the ball carrier, covering running backs in the passing game, or rushing the quarterback.
What makes this pick especially smart is the Eagles’ need for a dynamic linebacker who can contribute in a variety of roles. Campbell’s ability to excel in both run defense and pass coverage makes him a perfect fit for the modern NFL, where versatility at linebacker is crucial. He has shown the ability to cover ground quickly, make explosive plays, and read the game at a high level, all qualities that will fit seamlessly into Philadelphia’s aggressive defensive scheme.
Trading up to grab Campbell is a strategic move to secure one of the draft’s most complete and athletic linebackers. This pick solidifies the Eagles’ defense for the future and provides them with a player who can immediately contribute, adding a dynamic element to their already talented unit.
Overall, this is an A-grade selection. The Eagles’ aggressive move up to grab Campbell pays off, as he has the potential to become a cornerstone piece of their defense for years to come.
1.32 Kansas City Chiefs (from Philadelphia) — Josh Simmons, T, Ohio State
Grade: B+
The Kansas City Chiefs selecting Josh Simmons, offensive tackle from Ohio State, after trading down from No. 31 to No. 32 is a solid and well-executed move. Simmons brings impressive size at 6’6” and 310 pounds, and his combination of athleticism and strength makes him a valuable asset to the Chiefs’ offensive line. He has the ability to play both tackle spots, offering flexibility to protect the quarterback’s blind side or secure the edge in the running game.
The value of the trade down to No. 32 is significant, as the Chiefs added a player who can provide depth and potential as a future starter without losing out on the caliber of talent they were targeting. Simmons’ skill set is well-suited for the Chiefs’ up-tempo offense, where quickness and the ability to protect a mobile quarterback like Patrick Mahomes are key.
However, the B+ grade reflects that Simmons still has areas for development. His technique can be inconsistent at times, particularly in his hand placement and ability to anchor against stronger pass rushers. His transition to the NFL will require refinement in these areas, but his raw talent gives him significant upside.
Overall, this is a smart and safe pick for the Chiefs. They addressed a need along the offensive line while maintaining good value with the trade down. Simmons may take some time to fully develop, but his potential as a long-term starter makes this a B+ pick with solid future value.